Without a Song…

I was browsing through comments on an old post at another blog, and I came across a fascinating discussion. A guy posting under the pseudonym of “soundcheck” was commenting on the vocal abilities of a couple of lead singers, both of whom he had worked with live and in the studio. He said that although the one had more popularity and name recognition, the other was unquestionably more talented. The way this guy put it was that singer A had gotten where he was because of “one group and one song,” while singer B had gotten where he was through raw vocal ability alone. (He then went on to add that they are both great guys and good friends of his, so he clearly wasn’t speaking out of spite—just honestly giving an opinion based on what he knew from personal experience.)

It got me thinking: Just how crucial is a signature song to a southern gospel singer’s success? Are there any SG singers who have achieved “star status” without that one hit that everybody knows and identifies with them? And can we observe the same phenomenon in other genres?

About these ads

7 Comments

Filed under Commentary

7 responses to “Without a Song…

  1. Scott Fowler has never had a “We Shall See Jesus” or “Oh What a Savior” moment.

    • True—and that reminds me that Mark Trammell doesn’t really have just one defining signature song either, but he’s the most highly respected baritone in the industry.

      • It may be true that Mark doesn’t have a signature song, but there are songs that he has sang that no one can match his signature voice on ..

        “Master Builder”, “Scars And Stripes”, “Sin Will Take You Farther” – to name a few.

    • Nate Stainbrook

      I believe that if L5/Daywind would have singled “Faithful To The Cross”, and if they (L5) would stage it more. That it could become a signature song for Fowler…

  2. Arthur Rice has been singing for years, yet he doesn’t have a signature song either.

  3. Ahh Matt you must be really NEW to SGM or Real Young or BOTH… you did not go see the Kingsmen when Artur sang with them and I have heard him do it several times with KH’s… “A Place Where the Hungry are Fed”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s